Pesticide and Environmental Update
Biotech Fact Sheet
Fast Facts
There are several kinds of genetically engineered crops being marketed
right now — mainly soybeans, cotton, corn and potatoes. These seeds are
altered mainly in two ways. Some have genes from bacteria spliced into
them to kill certain insects, usually with a natural toxin known as Bt.
For a complete explanation of this kind of crop, click here. Other crops
are altered to be able to withstand spraying of certain herbicides.
(Roundup Ready corn, for instance, is licensed by the same company that
makes Roundup herbicide: Monsanto.). For information on
herbicide-resistant crops, click here.
Genetically engineered foods are primarily created by splicing genes
from the DNA of an organism — plant, animal or microbe — and inserting
it into the genes of another organism meant for human consumption. This is
done through recombinant DNA techniques. Genetically engineered foods are
also referred to as transgenic foods and genetically modified organisms (GMOs).
In 1980, the U.S. Supreme Court by a 5-4 vote ruled that new life forms
can be patented, overturning a Patents and Trademark Office denial of a
patent for a genetically engineered microbe. The court decision moved the
research from academic labs into the commercial arena, with biotech
companies pouring billions into research of new life forms. To read the
Supreme Court opinion, click here. In 1990, the FDA approved the first
genetically engineered food product, chymosin. Chymosin is produced by
genetically engineered bacteria and functions like natural rennet, an
enzyme essential to cheese production that is traditionally obtained from
cows' stomachs. Chymosin is now used to make more than half of all cheese
produced in the U.S. The source of the new enzyme was E. Coli. To read the
FDA’s policy on chymosin and other foods created through biotechnology,
click here.
For the future, companies are working on foods they say will benefit
consumers by tasting better and including more nutrients. So far, the
benefits of the genetically engineered foods on the market are strictly
for the producers — ease of growing and delivery to stores. Recent
studies, however, have shown mixed results on whether farmers benefit from
using genetically engineered seeds.
Monsanto is the leader in developing genetically engineered seeds, with
AgrEvo, Novartis and DuPont/Pioneer also producing such seeds. The market
for genetically engineered seeds in the United States is controlled almost
exclusively by Monsanto, which has 88 percent of the market (based on area
planted in 1998). AgrEvo controlled 8 percent and Novartis, 4 percent,
according to the Rural Advancement Foundation International. There are at
least 36 genetically engineered crops patented so far. For a complete
list, click here.
Internal FDA reports and memos reveal that the agency's own scientists
disagreed about the safety of genetically engineered foods before the
agency issued rulings on how such foods would be tested. But in 1992, the
FDA ruled that genetically engineered foods do not have to be labeled.
Thus they are mixed into the food supply undistinguished from
unadulterated crops.
Along with the DNA spliced into a crop, a marker gene is inserted so
that the plant can be tested to see if the insertion was successful. (This
is necessary because genetic engineers cannot predict if or where the
foreign gene will attach in the new cell; the marker allows them to
determine which cells experienced a successful insertion.) Commonly used
are bacterial genes that confer resistance to an antibiotic, which can
lead to increased resistance to antibiotics in people eating such food.
Since cells normally fight off anything foreign, a promoter gene is
also inserted to help override the cell's defenses and promote the
intended function of the inserted gene. To work, strong, aggressive
promoters -- such as viruses and bacteria are needed. Frequently used is
the Cauliflower Mosaic Virus because it is a strong promoter and has a
high species-compatibility. Some geneticists believe inserting foreign
viruses into cells could lead to the creation of new viruses. >From
1986 to 1997, approximately 25,000 field trials on genetically engineered
crops were conducted by 45 countries on more than 60 crops and 10 traits,
according to the Rural Advancement Foundation International. Of this
total, 15,000 field trials were conducted during the first ten-year
period, and 10,000 in the last two years. Almost 280 billion acres of
genetically engineered crops were grown worldwide in 1998. Soybeans,
maize, cotton, canola/rapeseed and potatoes were the five principal
genetically engineered crops grown in 1998, according to RAFI.
|